Comments on: Liveblogging: The X Factor 2009 : Live Results 5 http://www.oneknightstands.net/liveblogging-the-x-factor-2009-live-results-5/ Tue, 09 Mar 2010 23:24:56 -0800 http://wordpress.org/?v=2.9.2 hourly 1 By: sandra http://www.oneknightstands.net/liveblogging-the-x-factor-2009-live-results-5/comment-page-1/#comment-7912 sandra Thu, 12 Nov 2009 22:16:53 +0000 http://www.oneknightstands.net/?p=1037#comment-7912 Yes I believe it should be only a public vote. This stuff with the judges deciding on a show down is just rubbish..What do they decide? The last 2 weeks.. nothing! Both times they put the best singer out..Its just a farce with each judge siding with their own act. If they are not going to judge on the performance in the showdown, then why go through the charade? Just let the public decide. I didn't like what Simon did, seemed to me like he was more interested in keeping in an act that obviously brings in a lot of telephone votes (revenue), than he was in judging talent. However he didn't put Lucy in last place..The public did..fair enough. Yes I believe it should be only a public vote. This stuff with the judges deciding on a show down is just rubbish..What do they decide? The last 2 weeks.. nothing! Both times they put the best singer out..Its just a farce with each judge siding with their own act. If they are not going to judge on the performance in the showdown, then why go through the charade? Just let the public decide. I didn't like what Simon did, seemed to me like he was more interested in keeping in an act that obviously brings in a lot of telephone votes (revenue), than he was in judging talent. However he didn't put Lucy in last place..The public did..fair enough.

]]> By: Sujoy http://www.oneknightstands.net/liveblogging-the-x-factor-2009-live-results-5/comment-page-1/#comment-7906 Sujoy Wed, 11 Nov 2009 11:37:43 +0000 http://www.oneknightstands.net/?p=1037#comment-7906 I know, there is a bloody reason to keep that format. Otherwise avoid all bloody confusion, and make it straight to Audience voting numbers. Simon has lost all credibility as a judge. If this continues, the public will start voting erroneously and make Jedward the winner of this season. Consider that Simon - you gonna sign a record contract with them, and they are gonna vanish in a blink. <br>This is serious shit...sort it out Simon. He is not a man of his own words. After all those comments on Jedward, he chickens out. Shame !! I know, there is a bloody reason to keep that format. Otherwise avoid all bloody confusion, and make it straight to Audience voting numbers. Simon has lost all credibility as a judge. If this continues, the public will start voting erroneously and make Jedward the winner of this season. Consider that Simon – you gonna sign a record contract with them, and they are gonna vanish in a blink.
This is serious shit…sort it out Simon. He is not a man of his own words. After all those comments on Jedward, he chickens out. Shame !!

]]> By: Sujoy http://www.oneknightstands.net/liveblogging-the-x-factor-2009-live-results-5/comment-page-1/#comment-7907 Sujoy Wed, 11 Nov 2009 11:34:55 +0000 http://www.oneknightstands.net/?p=1037#comment-7907 Lucie doesn't have the public behind her, coz her performance wasn't good enough on the previous night. But yes, considering that she has the potential to be a good singer, she could've delivered a kick-ass performance in the future, and if Simon's acts did not deliver on that very day - like if Mr.Danyl was in a different state of mind, then of course, Simon's acts wud b endangered. That's the whole strategy. Eliminate all the possible potential singers. Lucie doesn't have the public behind her, coz her performance wasn't good enough on the previous night. But yes, considering that she has the potential to be a good singer, she could've delivered a kick-ass performance in the future, and if Simon's acts did not deliver on that very day – like if Mr.Danyl was in a different state of mind, then of course, Simon's acts wud b endangered. That's the whole strategy. Eliminate all the possible potential singers.

]]> By: Annie http://www.oneknightstands.net/liveblogging-the-x-factor-2009-live-results-5/comment-page-1/#comment-7905 Annie Wed, 11 Nov 2009 08:54:01 +0000 http://www.oneknightstands.net/?p=1037#comment-7905 But don't you think it's a little bit awkward that after commening negatively Jedward so many times, Simon when having a chance to shoot them off the competition, he let the audience decide? It rose a question if the judges' votings are at all needed, if almost every week (except ricky/rachel results) it goes to deadlock. it should be left to audience decision without judges' messing up with it. That's my opinion. But don't you think it's a little bit awkward that after commening negatively Jedward so many times, Simon when having a chance to shoot them off the competition, he let the audience decide? It rose a question if the judges' votings are at all needed, if almost every week (except ricky/rachel results) it goes to deadlock. it should be left to audience decision without judges' messing up with it. That's my opinion.

]]> By: Rojhat http://www.oneknightstands.net/liveblogging-the-x-factor-2009-live-results-5/comment-page-1/#comment-7903 Rojhat Wed, 11 Nov 2009 07:55:42 +0000 http://www.oneknightstands.net/?p=1037#comment-7903 Guys u're all a bit wrong about Simon. I like him and he didn't vote Lucie out because she was a good singer and could cause trouble to his acts. NO ! xD She wouldn't never have made it to the top because she couldn't connect with the public either just like Rachel. SO she absolutely couldn't cause any trouble to his acts because she doesn't has the public behind her and Simons acts do have the public so also teh votes. And appearently Jedward have more people than her. And tbh I think we already got alot singer that are like Lucie. Guys u're all a bit wrong about Simon. I like him and he didn't vote Lucie out because she was a good singer and could cause trouble to his acts. NO ! xD She wouldn't never have made it to the top because she couldn't connect with the public either just like Rachel. SO she absolutely couldn't cause any trouble to his acts because she doesn't has the public behind her and Simons acts do have the public so also teh votes. And appearently Jedward have more people than her. And tbh I think we already got alot singer that are like Lucie.

]]> By: Sujoy http://www.oneknightstands.net/liveblogging-the-x-factor-2009-live-results-5/comment-page-1/#comment-7902 Sujoy Tue, 10 Nov 2009 08:53:25 +0000 http://www.oneknightstands.net/?p=1037#comment-7902 I know Idol has that format of totally relying on the audience. But the X Factor format asks for the judges to decide who goes home from the Bottom 2. Simon's decision over the last two weeks has not been well received. There have been complaints being written to ITV over these. And Simon has lost all credibility as a judge.<br><br>He is simply doing this coz he wants the better singers eliminated so that his acts can stay longer in the competition. How lame is that. I know Idol has that format of totally relying on the audience. But the X Factor format asks for the judges to decide who goes home from the Bottom 2. Simon's decision over the last two weeks has not been well received. There have been complaints being written to ITV over these. And Simon has lost all credibility as a judge.

He is simply doing this coz he wants the better singers eliminated so that his acts can stay longer in the competition. How lame is that.

]]> By: Kris http://www.oneknightstands.net/liveblogging-the-x-factor-2009-live-results-5/comment-page-1/#comment-7901 Kris Tue, 10 Nov 2009 00:00:20 +0000 http://www.oneknightstands.net/?p=1037#comment-7901 I am sorry...bad typos, bad habbit....I was trying to say in the past couple of years that I have been watching Xfactor, from my observations the judges (doesnt matter which judge) always take the decision to public vote...I am wondering if that would be the reason simon has picked the public vote the last two weeks because it is kind of obvious that rachel was better then lloyd and lucie better then john and edward....hopefully this makes a bit more sense in what i am trying to say, because these are my thoughts...and what do you think I am sorry…bad typos, bad habbit….I was trying to say in the past couple of years that I have been watching Xfactor, from my observations the judges (doesnt matter which judge) always take the decision to public vote…I am wondering if that would be the reason simon has picked the public vote the last two weeks because it is kind of obvious that rachel was better then lloyd and lucie better then john and edward….hopefully this makes a bit more sense in what i am trying to say, because these are my thoughts…and what do you think

]]> By: Sujoy http://www.oneknightstands.net/liveblogging-the-x-factor-2009-live-results-5/comment-page-1/#comment-7877 Sujoy Mon, 09 Nov 2009 07:24:02 +0000 http://www.oneknightstands.net/?p=1037#comment-7877 U mean the Pet Shop Boys.. what Cheryl says, no one cares. I don't like her song even, and the Girls Aloud stuff. So her opinion doesn't really matter. And so does of the mental Louis Walsh.<br><br>I am sorry to have confused your location. Your IP address says that you are located in Warsaw. So got a bit messed up. I would like to visit Poland some day :) And glad to know that British reality talent competition is popular out there. <br><br>And thanks for the holiday wishes. CHeers Annie. See you next week :) U mean the Pet Shop Boys.. what Cheryl says, no one cares. I don't like her song even, and the Girls Aloud stuff. So her opinion doesn't really matter. And so does of the mental Louis Walsh.

I am sorry to have confused your location. Your IP address says that you are located in Warsaw. So got a bit messed up. I would like to visit Poland some day :) And glad to know that British reality talent competition is popular out there.

And thanks for the holiday wishes. CHeers Annie. See you next week :)

]]>